‘Immoral and unethical’: Ombudsman slams WorkCover scheme and WorkSafe.


‘Immoral and unethical’: Ombudsman slams WorkCover scheme and WorkSafe.

The Victorian Ombudsman has finalised its follow-up review from the 2016 investigation into the WorkCover scheme. Unfortunately, and perhaps unsurprisingly, nothing much has changed from the 2016 findings. Workers are still being taken advantage of by greedy Insurance companies.

Here’s the transcript of an article from The Age from 3 December 2019 by Sumeyya Ilanbey and Benjamin Preiss:

WorkSafe insurance agents are continuing to deny legitimate claims for worker’s compensation, in decisions the state’s ombudsman has slammed as “immoral and unethical”.

Victorian Ombudsman Deborah Glass released her follow-up report into her 2016 investigation, which found insurance agents were unfairly denying WorkCover claims for financial incentives.

In a scathing statement on Tuesday morning, Ms Glass said her 2016 investigation had “only scratched the surface”.

“I said in 2016 these cases involve people’s lives, and the human cost should never be forgotten; that human cost continues to this day,” Ms Glass said.

“Many of the decisions and actions we saw were not only unjust and wrong. Some were downright immoral and unethical.”

Ms Glass was also critical of the regulator WorkSafe, which she said even when unethical decisions made by agents were brought to its attention, WorkSafe did not intervene or require the agents to overturn their decisions.

She said the regulator “appeared reluctant” to deal with agents making unreasonable decisions, which raised “the troubling prospect that WorkSafe feels beholden to the agents and dependent on their participation to deliver a financially viable scheme”.

In one case that has been slammed by Ms Glass, an aged care worker was unfairly surveilled without adequate justification.

The investigation also uncovered that a factory’s workers payments were terminated when he failed to take part in occupational rehabilitation, despite experiencing psychotic hallucinations.

In relation to a police officer who developed post-traumatic stress disorder after attending traumatic events, an independent medical examiner (IME) concluded in 2017 the man was indefinitely incapacitated for all work, Ms Glass’ report states.

“However, the agent tried to change the IME’s opinion by highlighting that the man played golf, asking ‘Would this not translate to a partial capacity for suitable alternative employment or capacity to participate in occupational services?’

“The IME then said it was ‘possible’ the man had improved since he saw him and that he could now participate in occupational rehabilitation, to which he was then referred. The man complained to WorkSafe, saying the IME’s claims were ‘baseless’ and a ‘guess’, not an opinion.”

WorkSafe chief executive Colin Radford said improvements introduced after the Ombudsman’s 2016 investigation had “unfortunately not been enough”.

“No one chooses to be injured at work. When injuries or illness do occur, workers deserve to be treated with empathy and respect and to receive the right support and the right entitlements in a timely manner,” he said. “To those injured workers for whom this has regrettably not been the case, I apologise.”

In a statement, Attorney-General Jill Hennessy said the report revealed disturbing examples of workers being unfairly treated and unjustly denied their legal entitlements.

“I have written to the board of WorkSafe detailing my expectation that the recommendations are actioned quickly, in particular to ensure injured workers have access to a timely independent review of their case,” she said.

Two recommendations made to the government have been accepted. It has agreed to commission a review into the current models of claims management to ensure that appropriate compensation is paid to injured workers who have complex claims. It will also introduce a new dispute resolution process.

Ms Hennessy said 13 recommendations made to WorkSafe had also been accepted.


Here is the link to the original article:


Been injured and seeking compensation?

We can help you whether you've been injured at work, in a motor vehicle collision or due to a defective product or assault. Contact us to talk to one of our lawyers about your case. It's free and confidential.

About the author

kauthenlegal administrator